Links
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(141)
-
▼
May 2007
(20)
- A hybrid today keeps global warming away
- Lucas Oil Stadium
- Chavez: Just another thug
- Straws in the wind - the "shh, don't mention the H...
- Torture
- An Inconvenient Graph
- Big Brother (the show) meets Big Brother (government)
- Another One Bites the Dust
- Cool Sunday in May: Global Warming's a'comin'
- To Z or not to Z
- Jerry Falwell, RIP
- Book Review
- Christianity Debated
- Giuliani and abortion
- Change in France?
- Signs of the Times
- Hatemonger's Quarterly
- Warning: More Global Warming Skepticism Ahead!
- Ave Atque Vale
- Legalese, Spin Doctoring, and Moral Sensitivity
-
▼
May 2007
(20)
Labels
Thursday, May 24, 2007
This story has been out there for a couple weeks, but only today did I read Mark Steyn's Western Standard piece regarding this issue. To recount for those who may have not heard this story, some teachers in England have stopped teaching about the Holocaust because some of their students (i.e. Muslims) get a bit agitated when they hear something that contradicts what they are hearing at home. So to appease the willfully ignorant, history is swept under the rug. As Steyn mulled,
[Avoiding offense] is what most of us want to do, because if you're "causing offence" it can get pretty exhausting. In the Middle East, for example, I'm like those British and European schoolma'ams: on the whole, I avoid bringing up the Holocaust--in part because in the Muslim world it's a subject impervious to reason, but also because it's very disheartening to meet folks who are bright, witty, engaging, perceptive and then 40 minutes into the conversation you mention the Jews and discover that your bright, witty, engaging, et cetera companion is, at a certain level, nuts.
...
Last year, a poll found that 37 per cent of British Muslims agreed that British Jews are a legitimate target "as part of the ongoing struggle for justice in the Middle East." Who wants to argue with that every time you mention the Second World War? Best just to drop the subject.
In 1984, George Orwell wrote, "Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past." The Muslim community in Europe does not yet "control" anything: they are, relatively, small in numbers, though big in certain cities and bigger still in the schools of those cities. Nevertheless, it is significant that, though still quite a long way from formal "control," they are already determining the shape of the future, and thus of the past. The Holocaust did happen. Millions did die. "Facts," said John Adams, "are stubborn things." But not in the Europe of 2007. Faced with serving a population far more stubborn than any mere fact, Continental teachers are quietly putting reality up for grabs. It's a small thing, initially--the sin of omission, of discreetly gliding over "controversy" in the interests of multicultural sensitivity.
...
These are straws in the wind, but there will be many more of them from a political and bureaucratic class anxious to avoid "causing offence." What other bits of reality will be chipped away from the curriculum in the years ahead? And will what's left be enough to glue a nation together? After all, if you can't agree on the past, you're unlikely to agree on the future.
A few months ago, I met the splendid prime minister of Australia, John Howard, on the day of a new education initiative to get the country's history taught (as he put it) as an "heroic national narrative." It's a marvelous phrase, but in Britain and much of Europe the classroom can no longer agree on who are the heroes and who are the villains.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment